Why Calorie Counting May Not Be the Key to Weight Loss—And Why Protein Matters More

Why Calorie Counting May Not Be the Key to Weight Loss—And Why Protein Matters More

For decades, weight loss advice centred around a simple equation: calories in versus calories out.

But emerging science and real-world results increasingly show that focusing solely on calorie counting often fails—especially for women in midlife.

Here's why calorie quality, not just quantity, matters, and why prioritising protein is far more effective for sustainable weight loss, muscle retention, and overall health.

And Zing Wellbeing Founder Rhian, has shared her own weight loss story where she didn't count calories and instead focused on protein, gut health, sleep and lifting weights - you can read her story here.

1. Not All Calories Are Equal

While technically a calorie is a unit of energy, the body doesn’t process all calories in the same way. For example:

  • 100 calories of sugar spikes insulin, promotes fat storage, and leads to cravings.

  • 100 calories of protein takes more energy to digest and helps build lean muscle, which burns more calories at rest.

A study in JAMA (2012) found that people who ate lower-carb, higher-protein diets burned more calories at rest than those on high-carb diets, even at the same calorie intake.

2. Calorie Counting Ignores Hormonal Impact

For women, especially in perimenopause and menopause, hormonal shifts make weight loss harder. Calorie counting doesn’t address:

  • Insulin resistance (common with age and inflammation)

  • Leptin and ghrelin imbalances (appetite hormones)

  • Cortisol spikes from stress and under-eating

These hormonal disruptions can cause the body to hold onto fat, even when eating fewer calories.

3. Protein Preserves Muscle and Metabolism

Protein is essential for fat loss—not just for gym-goers, but especially for women over 40 who naturally lose muscle mass each decade. Here’s why:

  • Muscle burns more calories than fat, even at rest.

  • Protein has the highest thermic effect of food (TEF)—meaning your body burns more calories digesting it.

  • Adequate protein intake reduces cravings and keeps you full longer.

One study in The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition showed people on a high-protein diet lost more fat and preserved more lean muscle compared to those on standard diets—even when calories were the same.

4. Calorie Counting Often Leads to Undereating

Many women unknowingly under-eat when counting calories—especially protein. This can:

  • Slow metabolism

  • Increase muscle loss

  • Trigger rebound weight gain

  • Lead to fatigue, poor mood, and nutrient deficiencies

Instead, focusing on eating enough of the right foods—especially protein, fibre, and healthy fats—leads to better long-term results.

5. A Better Approach: Protein-First, Whole-Food Focus

Rather than obsessively tracking every calorie, aim for this instead:

  • 1.5–2g of protein per kg of body weight per day (more if active or over 40)

  • Prioritise whole foods: lean protein, vegetables, legumes, nuts, and minimally processed carbs

  • Eat balanced meals that support blood sugar stability and satiety

In Summary

Calorie counting might create awareness, but it’s not the magic key to weight loss—especially for women in midlife.

Prioritising protein helps preserve metabolism, control hunger, and support hormonal balance.

The shift from quantity to quality is what makes weight loss sustainable, empowering, and health-focused.

Back to blog